Olay 289159 Night Cream Review
Our verdict
Olay's 289159 oil-free night cream for dry skin is a hydration-focused product in a 2 fl oz format, but its 3.9-star average from 240 reviews is the lowest in the Olay lineup reviewed here, suggesting buyer response is more divided than typical for the brand.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Dry-skin adults who want an oil-free Olay night moisturizer and do not require active anti-aging ingredients like retinol or AHA.
Skip if
You want a higher-rated option, are sensitive to price given the modest 2 fl oz size at $47.96, or need key actives like vitamin C or retinol in your overnight formula.
- Form Cream
- Skin type Dry
- Benefits Hydrating
- Targets Nourishing
- Size 2 Fluid Ounces
- Free of Oil Free
- Priced 87% above the category median ($25.71 across 144 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating3.9/5
3.9 average across 240 owner ratings
-
Popularity1.9/5
240 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other anti-aging skincare: serums, night creams, facial peels, wrinkle patches and anti-aging devices we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
['Olay 289159 is positioned as a hydrating cream for dry skin with an oil-free formulation. For dry skin types, an oil-free formula can seem counterintuitive, but oil-free does not mean moisture-free. These products typically rely on humectants and emollients rather than occlusive oils to deliver moisture without a greasy finish.', 'The product targets nourishing concerns and comes in at 2 fl oz. No key ingredients are listed in the spec data, which limits the ability to assess the formula in depth. At $47.96 for 2 fl oz, it sits at a premium price tier for an Olay product, which may inform expectations around efficacy.', 'The 3.9-star average across 240 reviews is worth noting. While not a poor rating, it is below the 4.4 to 4.6 range common across other products in this category. Buyers with dry skin who tried this particular formula seem to have had more mixed experiences than those using other Olay variants.']
Pros
- Oil-free formulation avoids greasy residue on dry skin
- From a broadly trusted skincare brand
- Hydration-focused with a nourishing positioning
Cons
- 3.9-star average is below the category norm, indicating more mixed buyer experiences
- No key ingredients listed in available spec data
- $47.96 for 2 fl oz is priced at the premium end for this type of product
- Limited differentiating features compared to other Olay night creams
Specifications
- Form
- Cream
- Skin type
- Dry
- Benefits
- Hydrating
- Targets
- Nourishing
- Size
- 2 Fluid Ounces
- Free of
- Oil Free
- Age range
- Adult
Performance notes
Without disclosed key ingredients, performance can only be assessed through its positioning: oil-free hydration for dry skin, with a nourishing focus. Oil-free formulas for dry skin typically lean on glycerin, hyaluronic acid, or similar humectants to draw moisture into the skin without leaving an oily layer. The lower-than-average rating for this product within the broader lineup suggests that some buyers found the formula insufficient for their dry-skin needs at this price. Consistency of use over at least 4 to 6 weeks is typically needed to assess any moisturizer's impact on dry skin.
What buyers say
A 3.9-star average from 240 reviews places this below the typical night cream in this category. Buyers who rated it positively likely found adequate hydration, while those rating it lower may have expected more visible results given the price. The rating gap versus other Olay products suggests this particular formula has not resonated as consistently. Questions about value for money appear more frequently in the review pool than for comparable products.
More from Olay
Similar anti-aging skincare: serums, night creams, facial peels, wrinkle patches and anti-aging devices to consider
Frequently asked questions
Why is an oil-free cream recommended for dry skin?
Oil-free does not mean the cream lacks moisture. It means it avoids heavy plant or mineral oils that can feel greasy or clog pores. For dry skin, an oil-free formula can still deliver solid hydration through humectants and emollients, and it tends to feel lighter on the skin, which some dry-skin users actually prefer.
Is the $47.96 price typical for Olay night creams?
Olay's product range spans from around $9 to $73 depending on the line and formula. At $47.96, this sits at the mid-to-upper end. Given the 3.9-star average, shoppers comparing options may want to evaluate whether a differently rated Olay formula at a different price point better matches their dry-skin needs and budget.