Olay PROCTER145904 Night Cream Review
Our verdict
At $9.20, this Olay night cream for dry skin delivers a 4.6 star rating across 372 reviews, which is exceptional for a sub-$10 moisturizer. It is a straightforward overnight hydrator targeting the look of firmer skin, and the price-to-satisfaction ratio here is hard to beat.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Adults with dry skin who want a dependable, affordable overnight moisturizer that targets the appearance of firming without spending more than $10.
Skip if
You need key actives like vitamin C, retinol, or glycolic acid in your night cream, or your skin is oily to combination and you prefer a lighter texture.
- Form Cream
- Skin type Dry
- Benefits Hydrating
- Targets Firming
- Size 60 Milliliters
- Age range Adult
- Priced 64% below the category median ($25.71 across 144 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.6/5
4.6 average across 372 owner ratings
-
Popularity2.8/5
372 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other anti-aging skincare: serums, night creams, facial peels, wrinkle patches and anti-aging devices we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
["This Olay night cream is priced at $9.20 for a 60 ml tube, making it one of the most accessible night creams in the firming category. It is formulated for dry skin and carries a firming benefit claim. While specific key ingredients are not listed in the product data, the Olay brand's longstanding formulation expertise in overnight moisturizers supports its credibility in this positioning.", "The cream form and 60 ml size are standard for a night cream, and the dry-skin focus suggests a richer texture than Olay's oil-free variants. The product is positioned as hydrating with a firming benefit, which aligns well with what dry skin typically needs from an overnight formula: sustained moisture retention and a plumper surface appearance by morning.", '372 reviews at 4.6 stars is a legitimately strong signal at this price. Buyers who use this product appear overwhelmingly satisfied, and the review volume is sufficient to represent a consistent performance pattern rather than a lucky early batch of ratings.']
Pros
- Exceptional value at $9.20 for 60 ml
- 4.6 rating across 372 reviews is among the highest for this price tier
- Formulated specifically for dry skin needs
- Trusted Olay brand at an entry-level price
- 60 ml is a generous size for the cost
Cons
- No key ingredients listed, so it is difficult to assess the active formula
- Limited to dry skin; not suitable for combination or oily skin types
- No AHAs, retinol, or brightening actives for more targeted anti-aging
- May feel too heavy for warm-weather use if you run warm at night
Specifications
- Form
- Cream
- Skin type
- Dry
- Benefits
- Hydrating
- Targets
- Firming
- Size
- 60 Milliliters
- Age range
- Adult
Performance notes
Without a listed key ingredient, the performance of this cream rests on its formulation as a rich overnight moisturizer for dry skin. Cream-based night formulas for dry skin typically use occlusive agents (such as petrolatum or mineral oil) alongside emollients and humectants to lock moisture in while the skin's overnight repair processes are most active. The firming benefit claim is consistent with the idea that well-hydrated skin appears plumper and more elastic by morning.
What buyers say
A 4.6 average over 372 reviews at under $10 is a noteworthy outcome. Dry skin buyers who find a product that works consistently tend to become loyal repeat purchasers, which likely contributes to the sustained high rating. Negative feedback in this category often comes from users who expected more actives or more dramatic change than a basic overnight moisturizer can deliver.
More from Olay
Similar anti-aging skincare: serums, night creams, facial peels, wrinkle patches and anti-aging devices to consider
Frequently asked questions
Can I use this under my eyes as well?
This cream is formulated as a general face night moisturizer for dry skin, not as a dedicated eye cream. The skin around the eyes is thinner and more sensitive, and using a regular face cream in that area may cause puffiness for some people. A dedicated eye cream with appropriate dosing for that area is generally a better choice for under-eye concerns.
How long will a 60 ml tube last?
Used nightly with a pea-to-dime-size amount, 60 ml typically lasts six to ten weeks depending on how much you apply. Dry skin users who layer product more generously may go through it faster, while lighter applicators can stretch it further.